Exams › JEE Advanced › Chemistry

For the following pair of cations, state which one is more stable: (I) the benzyl cation, C6H5-CH2(+), and (II) the allyl cation, CH2=CH-CH2(+).

1. (I) benzyl cation is more stable because it is stabilised by an aromatic ring (resonance over the ring)
2. (II) allyl cation is more stable
3. Both are equally stable
4. Neither is resonance stabilised

Correct answer: (I) benzyl cation is more stable because it is stabilised by an aromatic ring (resonance over the ring)

Solution

The benzyl cation C6H5-CH2(+) delocalises its positive charge into the benzene ring, giving four important resonance structures (charge on the benzylic carbon plus the ortho and para ring carbons). The allyl cation CH2=CH-CH2(+) delocalises charge over only two carbons (two equivalent resonance structures). More extensive delocalisation lowers the energy more, so the benzyl cation is more stable than the allyl cation.

Related JEE Advanced Chemistry questions

• When N₂ is converted to N₂⁺, what happens to the bond dissociation energy of the N–N bond, and when O₂ is converted to O₂⁺, what happens to the bond dissociation energy of the O–O bond?
• In which of these ions is pπ–dπ bonding absent?
• What is the VSEPR formula for the chlorine trifluoride molecule?
• Consider the following molecules: CO2, SO2, and H2O. Arrange them in ascending order of their dipole moments.
• Which of the following occurrences is primarily influenced by hydrogen bonding?
• When two 1s atomic orbitals (one from each atom) combine to form molecular orbitals, which of the following statements is correct?

⚔️ Practice JEE Advanced Chemistry free + battle 1v1 →