Correct answer: It is neutral
Repulsion (2,3) and (4,5) proves balls 2 and 4 are charged. Ball 1 attracts BOTH 2 and 4. If 1 were charged, it could not be opposite in sign to both 2 and 4 unless 2 and 4 carried the same sign - but a charged ball attracting two same-sign balls is impossible. The only consistent possibility is that ball 1 is neutral, attracting charged balls by induction.